Airborne Babies Safer Even Unbelted?

Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • A proposed FAA regulation requiring infant restraint seats on airplanes is opposed by pediatricians who argue it could increase infant deaths by prompting families to choose more dangerous car travel instead of flying.
  • The pediatricians claim the rule would save only about four lives over 10 years and is economically impractical.
  • The estimated cost per life saved for the regulation is extremely high at $1.3 billion, suggesting funds could be better spent on other safety initiatives.
See a mistake? Contact us.

Baby seats in airplanes may sound like a good idea but they might actually increase the number of babies that die — in car crashes. A report by a group of pediatricians says a proposed FAA regulation that would require infant restraint seats for children under the age of two doesn’t make practical or economic sense. The suggested logic (flawed or not) is that having to buy a seat for a tot that can now sit on Mom or Dad’s lap for free would push some families to drive instead of fly. The report offers that the family car is a much more perilous environment for a baby than flying commercially (they haven’t discovered stress yet) so the pediatricians want the FAA to put the brakes on the regulation. According to the doctors, the baby-restraint rule would save only about four deaths in 10 years. If only 5 to 10 percent of families chose to drive instead of fly because of the increased cost, more babies would die on the road, the doctors claim. They also point out that if the average fare for a strapped-in baby was $200, the average cost per life saved would be $1.3 billion. “Many more lives could be saved by spending this money on other safety measures,” said Dr. Thomas Newman, the study’s main author.

Sign-up for newsletters & special offers!

Get the latest stories & special offers delivered directly to your inbox

SUBSCRIBE

Please support AVweb.

It looks like you’re using an ad blocker. Ads keep AVweb free and fund our reporting.
Please whitelist AVweb or continue with ads enabled.