Consequences: Pilot, Mechanic Faulted For “Reckless” Flight…

Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • A pilot received a five-month certificate suspension (reduced from six) for a "reckless" emergency freeway landing of a rented Piper Cherokee, which severely injured an 11-year-old girl, despite knowing the engine had trouble.
  • The mechanic who worked on the aircraft also had his certificate suspended for 250 days (reduced from 330) for improper maintenance that contributed to the engine's malfunction.
  • Both the pilot and mechanic are facing a pending civil lawsuit from the injured girl's family, alleging negligence in the aircraft's maintenance and operation.
See a mistake? Contact us.

The Cost Of A Choice

A pilot who made an emergency landing on a California freeway in April 2004 won some consideration in an appeal before an NTSB judge in Denver last week. In October, the FAA had ordered a six-month suspension for “reckless” behavior, but the NTSB reduced it to five months. The pilot and his passenger were unharmed in the landing, but the rented Piper Cherokee’s wing sliced through a van, nearly severing the leg of an 11-year-old girl. The mechanic who worked on the airplane before the flight also lost his certificate, for 250 days, reduced from the FAA’s 330-day penalty. Investigators found that the mechanic didn’t fix the rented aircraft properly, and the pilot knew it was having engine trouble but chose to fly anyway, according to The Monterey Herald. The airplane was destroyed in a post-impact fire. Both men have the option to appeal further to an NTSB court in Washington, D.C. A civil suit filed by the girl’s family, alleging negligence in the maintenance and operation of the airplane, is pending in Contra Costa Superior Court, the Herald reported.

Sign-up for newsletters & special offers!

Get the latest stories & special offers delivered directly to your inbox

SUBSCRIBE