Short Final

Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • An air traffic controller requested a B-727 pilot to perform a difficult maneuver: descend steeply to a specific altitude while also slowing down to 250 knots.
  • The pilot humorously highlighted the physical impossibility of simultaneously rapid descent and deceleration by attributing the limitation to "Newton."
  • The controller appreciated the witty remark and rephrased the request, acknowledging the "energy management problem" faced by the aircraft.
  • The situation arose due to a last-minute change in ORD's landing configuration, leaving incoming planes at higher altitudes than desired.
See a mistake? Contact us.

We were approaching ORD from the east years ago in a B-727, which was famous for being able to descend very steeply, as long as it was not speed-restricted. ORD approach was changing from an east landing configuration to west, meaning that the airplanes over Lake Michigan were all going to end up high because of the change in plans.

ORD Controller (to a 727 ahead of us) :
“If I give you STORY intersection at 11,000 feet, can you make it down from there?”

727 Pilot:
“Yes, but we’ll have to start down right now.”

Controller:
“O.K., start down now; cross STORY at 11,000. Oh, and I need you to do that at 250 knots.”

727 Pilot:
“Hey, we can’t come down and slow down at the same time.”

Controller (unsure who was giving him a hard time, since the 727 pilot hadn’t used his callsign) :
“Who said that?”

727 Pilot:
“Uh, I think it was Newton.”

Controller (laughing) :
“I guess I deserved that. O.K., which aircraft is anticipating an energy management problem?”

Several of us jumped in and said, “We are!” all at the same time.

As a former physics major, this one really cracked me up. One usually thinks of a comeback line like that on the drive home, instead of instantly as this fellow did.


Ron Cox
via e-mail

Sign-up for newsletters & special offers!

Get the latest stories & special offers delivered directly to your inbox

SUBSCRIBE