Short Final

Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • An aviator observed a humorous communication breakdown between El Monte Tower and a helicopter pilot during an approach.
  • The tower's request to "say parking" was repeatedly misinterpreted by the pilot as a literal command to utter the word "parking."
  • The amusing exchange was likened to the "Who's on First" routine, a sentiment shared and confirmed by the tower controller after the event.
See a mistake? Contact us.

Last week, while helping a friend move his airplane from El Monte airport to Hawthorne airport, we were on approach into El Monte when I heard the aviation equivalent of “Who’s on First”:

El Monte Tower:
“Helicopter 11 Alpha, say parking.”

Helicopter 11A (heavy foreign accent) :
“Uh, please repeat.”

El Monte Tower:
“Helicopter 11 Alpha, say parking.”

Helicopter 11A:
“Alpha, Parking.”

El Monte Tower (using a slow, deliberate tone) :
“Helicopter One-One-Alpha: Say parking on El Monte Airport.”

Helicopter 11A:“Parking on El Monte airport, Helicopter 11 Alpha.”

A slight pause in the interchange, and then:

Helicopter 11A:“11 Alpha requesting take-off with left downwind departure.”

I landed uneventfully, dropped off my friend at his hangar, and taxied back out for take-off. When I was cleared for take-off and while taxiing onto the runway, I asked:

(Me, to the Tower):
“Do you suppose that guy in the helicopter ever figured out who’s on first?”

El Monte Tower (uproarious laughter in the background) :
“I doubt it.”

Bill Allen
via e-mail

Sign-up for newsletters & special offers!

Get the latest stories & special offers delivered directly to your inbox

SUBSCRIBE